Customer reviews help you pick a restaurant, a salon or a tradesperson, but some are fake, paid for or written by competitors. Here are the warning signs and what the law says about them.
Warning signs to look for
A single review tells you little. What matters is the overall picture: how regularly reviews appear, how varied the ratings are and how specific the comments are.
- Lots of glowing reviews in a short burst, then silence.
- Short, vague texts that all sound alike.
- Profiles with no photo, no history or a single review.
- Advertising language instead of a real account of an experience.
- Details that do not fit, such as a dish that is not on the menu.
Fake negative reviews exist too
A cluster of harsh, detail-free reviews posted on the same day may come from a competitor or someone with a grudge. Check whether the business replies and how: a calm, specific answer often tells you more than the rating.
Reading reviews the smart way
Start with recent reviews, then the middle-of-the-road ones: they are often the most balanced and useful. Look for points that come up again and again, good or bad.
Compare several sources when you can, for example Google reviews, the business website and a local directory.
What the law says
In France, posting or commissioning fake consumer reviews is a misleading commercial practice under the Consumer Code. A review given in exchange for something (a gift, a discount, a payment) must be presented as such.
Websites that publish reviews must also state clearly whether and how they check them. On the Guide Voxtya, submitted reviews are moderated before publication.
Where to report a fake review
Start with the report button on the website where the review appears. If you believe a company is misleading consumers with fake reviews, you can also report it on SignalConso, the official French site run by the consumer authority.
Frequently asked questions
Are businesses allowed to buy reviews?
No. Buying or writing fake reviews to mislead consumers is a misleading commercial practice. A review rewarded with something in return must be clearly labelled as such.
Is a perfect rating always suspicious?
Not necessarily, especially with only a few reviews. It becomes suspicious when there are many reviews, posted close together and worded in a similar way. Read the content, not just the score.
How do I report a fake review?
Use the report button on the site where the review is published. For misleading practices organised by a business, you can also file a report on SignalConso.
Are negative reviews more reliable?
Not always. They can be fake or exaggerated too. The most useful reviews are usually detailed and balanced, describing a specific experience.
Official sources: DGCCRF · SignalConso · Service-Public.fr
Do you run a local business?
Voxtya helps you collect reviews, reply to your customers and take bookings, all in one place.
Discover Voxtya →